The Blue Economy - CASE 34: New Sugars
This article introduces a creative approach to sweeteners as one of the 100 innovations that shape The Blue Economy., known as ZERIʼs philosophy in action. This article is part of a broad effort by the author and the designer of the Blue Economy to stimulate open-source entrepreneurship, competitiveness and employment. Researched, Written and Updated by Professor Gunter Pauli.
The Blue Economy Inspired Series
New Sugars:
The Evolution of Sweeteners in the Blue Economy
Written by; Shelley Tsang, 2024.
The search for innovative solutions to global challenges is a cornerstone of sustainable development, particularly within the framework of the Blue Economy, which emphasizes the responsible use of ocean resources for economic growth while ensuring the health of marine ecosystems. One fascinating area of innovation that fits this model is the development of new sweeteners, which is reshaping our approach to sugar consumption and its associated health risks. This article explores the evolution of sweeteners, focusing on the rise of synthetic and natural alternatives, particularly trehalose, and their potential impact on health and industry.
The Market Dynamics of Sweeteners
The global market for synthetic intense sweeteners was valued at $2.0 billion in 2010, reflecting a growing consumer demand for sugar alternatives that offer sweetness without calories. The first synthetic sweetener, saccharin, was discovered over 140 years ago and paved the way for subsequent innovations like aspartame, which was approved by the FDA in 1980. These sweeteners have become popular due to their ability to mimic the taste of sugar, appealing to consumers who wish to manage their caloric intake and reduce the risk of dental issues.
However, as awareness of health impacts associated with artificial sweeteners grew, consumers began shifting towards natural alternatives. By 2015, sales of natural sweeteners, particularly stevia, were expected to surpass those of synthetic sweeteners. This shift is driven by a consumer preference for ingredients perceived as healthier and more natural. Companies like Cargill, Coca-Cola, and PepsiCo have capitalized on this trend, launching numerous stevia-based products that significantly increased their market share.
The Search for the Ultimate Sweetener
The quest for ever-sweeter alternatives has led to the development of new synthetic sweeteners like sucralose, which is marketed under the brand Splenda and is 600 times sweeter than sugar. While these innovations present intriguing possibilities for the food industry, they also raise concerns about their long-term effects on health and the environment.
Research on sweeteners such as alitame and neotame—2,000 and 8,000 times sweeter than sucrose, respectively—has primarily focused on their taste and absorption. However, the potential impact on the human body, especially regarding the digestive system and overall health, remains insufficiently understood. This knowledge gap emphasizes the need for further research into the physiological effects of synthetic sweeteners, particularly their interaction with gastric acids and the potential to contribute to health issues if consumed in large quantities.
The Emergence of Trehalose: A Natural Breakthrough
Amid the exploration of synthetic sweeteners, a significant innovation has emerged: trehalose. This natural sugar, derived from the resurrection fern (Pleopeltis polypodioides), has garnered attention not just for its sweetness but for its remarkable properties that extend beyond traditional uses of sugar. Kazuhiko Maruta, a researcher at Hayashibara, discovered how to mass-produce trehalose from starch using naturally occurring enzymes, effectively cutting production costs and leading to widespread application in various industries.
Trehalose is unique in that it is not primarily valued for its sweetness. Instead, it offers numerous functional benefits, such as moisture retention, protein protection, and preservation of food quality. These properties make trehalose an ideal ingredient not only in the food industry but also in cosmetics and medical applications. Its ability to maintain freshness and prevent dehydration has made it a valuable additive in products ranging from frozen foods to skincare items.
Trehalose in Food and Health
The innovative production process for trehalose has led to its inclusion in over 20,000 products from approximately 7,000 companies within just 15 years of its discovery. This rapid growth illustrates the high demand for functional ingredients that address consumer health concerns and improve product quality. Research indicates that trehalose may also offer health benefits, particularly for individuals on high-fat diets. Studies on mice suggest that trehalose can enhance health indicators and regulate insulin production, thereby potentially mitigating risks associated with obesity and diabetes.
With an estimated 150 million people worldwide affected by obesity-related health issues, trehalose presents a promising avenue for developing functional foods and beverages that could improve overall health outcomes. Its multi-functional capabilities, including its role in preserving food and enhancing nutrient absorption, position trehalose as a vital ingredient in the ongoing fight against global health challenges.
Environmental Implications and the Blue Economy
The production and use of trehalose also align with the principles of the Blue Economy. By reducing reliance on synthetic alternatives and harnessing natural processes, trehalose manufacturing minimizes environmental impact while promoting sustainable practices. The ability to develop a product that not only serves the food industry but also supports health and wellness is a testament to the potential of the Blue Economy to innovate and address complex global issues.
Moreover, trehalose’s potential applications extend beyond food. Its ability to preserve organs for transplantation could revolutionize medical practices, reducing the need for refrigeration and the associated energy consumption. This innovation could significantly contribute to lowering fossil fuel dependency, further advancing sustainability goals.
Challenges and Future Opportunities
While the emergence of trehalose is promising, challenges remain. The initial production costs, despite being reduced significantly, still pose hurdles to widespread adoption in all segments of the market. Additionally, regulatory hurdles and the need for consumer education about the benefits of trehalose compared to other sweeteners are essential for driving acceptance.
However, the multifunctionality of trehalose presents an opportunity for further research and development. As the market for health-conscious products continues to grow, there is significant potential for innovation in creating new applications for trehalose and other natural sweeteners. Companies focusing on health-oriented consumer goods could find opportunities in formulating products that leverage the benefits of trehalose, catering to a market increasingly concerned with health, wellness, and sustainability.
Conclusion
The evolution of sweeteners, particularly the rise of trehalose, exemplifies how innovation can drive economic growth while addressing pressing health and environmental challenges. As the market shifts towards natural alternatives, the potential of trehalose extends far beyond traditional sweetness, offering solutions that align with the principles of the Blue Economy. By embracing such innovations, we can pave the way for a healthier future, where food, health, and environmental sustainability are inextricably linked. The journey towards this ideal begins with recognizing the potential of new sugars to transform our approach to consumption and industry. As we explore the possibilities, trehalose stands out as a beacon of innovation, illustrating the profound impact that a single discovery can have across multiple sectors of society.
Read More about the Blue Economy Database by ZERI China:
Publication and dissemination of this article, including translations, require prior written consent.
Please contact contacts@zeri-china.org